The Columbus Dispatch

TV antiheroin­es given their due, to a certain point

- By Mike Hale

at night — when Jane has no help. She leaves her daughter alone to retreat to her backyard studio to write; when she returns a few hours later, the girl is gone.

The ABC series is a having-it-all horror story with a perfect alignment of circumstan­ces to paint Jane as an imperfect mother.

What’s interestin­g, though, is that viewers aren’t pushed to like Jane. Her concern for her daughter is barely greater than her anger at the ex-husband she assumes is responsibl­e for the abduction and her fear that police will uncover her drug use.

In the British miniseries “Liar,” starting Sept. 27 on SundanceTV, Joanne Froggatt (“Downton Abbey”) plays a teacher who goes on a date with a widowed doctor (Ioan Gruffudd), then accuses him of drugging and raping her.

Writer-producer brothers Harry and Jack Williams (“The Missing”) hit many familiar beats in this story: Laura’s alcohol intake on the night in question, her jangled emotions and defensiven­ess afterward and a previous incident that casts doubt on her.

Perhaps no female TV protagonis­t is more troubled, though, than Robin Griffin, the Australian police detective played by Elisabeth Moss in “Top of the Lake: China Girl,” now in its second season on SundanceTV.

While probing the murders of Asian prostitute­s, Robin faces institutio­nal sexism and indifferen­ce that exacerbate the depression she suffers as a result of a rape as a teenager.

She’s also saddled with mother-guilt, having given up the child born after the rape. In classic femalenoir fashion, her personal demons both hinder her investigat­ion and give her the empathy and insight needed to pursue it.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States