The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

America lacks moral clarity as it seeks to impose values

- Pat Buchanan

Informing Iran, “The U.S. is watching what you do,” U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley called an emergency meeting last Friday of the Security Council regarding the riots in Iran. The session left her and us looking ridiculous.

France’s ambassador tutored Haley that how nations deal with internal disorders is not the council’s concern. Russia’s ambassador suggested the United Nations should have looked into our Occupy Wall Street clashes and how the Missouri cops handled Ferguson.

Fifty years ago, 100 U.S. cities erupted in flames after Martin Luther King’s assassinat­ion. Federal troops were called in. In 1992, Los Angeles suffered the worst U.S. riot of the 20th century, after the L.A. cops who pummeled Rodney King were acquitted in Simi Valley.

Was our handling of these riots any business of the U.N.?

Conservati­ves have demanded that the U.N. keep its nose out of our sovereign affairs since its birth in 1946. Do we now accept that the U.N. has authority to oversee internal disturbanc­es inside member countries?

Last Friday’s session fizzled out after Iran’s ambassador suggested the Security Council might take up the Israeli-Palestinia­n question or the humanitari­an crisis produced by the U.S.-backed Saudi war on Yemen.

The episode exposes a malady of American foreign policy. It lacks consistenc­y, coherence and moral clarity, treats friends and adversarie­s by separate standards, and is reflexivel­y interventi­onist.

Consider. Is Iran’s handling of these disorders more damnable than the thousands of extrajudic­ial killings of drug dealers attributed to our Filipino ally Rodrigo Duterte?

Vladimir Putin, too, is denounced for crimes against democracy for which our allies get a pass.

In Russia, Christiani­ty is flourishin­g and candidates are declaring against Putin. Some in the Russian press criticize him.

It is alleged that Putin’s regime is responsibl­e for the death of several journalist­s. But there are more journalist­s behind bars in the jails of our NATO ally Turkey than in any other country in the world.

What the world too often sees is an America that berates its adversarie­s for sins against our “values,” while giving allies a general absolution if they follow our lead.

In Putin’s Russia, the Communist Party is running a candidate against him. In China, the Communist Party exercises a monopoly of political power and nobody runs against Xi Jinping.

China’s annexation of the Paracel and Spratly Islands and the entire South China Sea is meekly protested, while Russia is castigated for its bloodless retrieval of a Crimean peninsula that was recognized as Russian territory under the Romanovs.

China is far the greater challenger to America’s standing as lone superpower. Why, then, this tilt toward China?

Among the reasons U.S. foreign policy lacks moral clarity is that we Americans no longer agree on what our vital interests are, who our real adversarie­s are, what our values are, or what a good and godly country looks like.

World War II and the Cold War gave us moral clarity. If you stood against Hitler, even if you were a monster like Joseph Stalin, we partnered with you.

But now that a worldwide conversion to democracy is no longer America’s mission in the world, what exactly is our mission?

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States