Thanksgiving lesson from grateful and prepared US families

Most Americans meticulously plan their Thanksgiving meals and travel, sometimes budgeting months in advance to celebrate at a reasonable price tag. This prudent embodiment of both gratitude and restraint starkly contrasts with the approach of our politicians. It’s an inconsistency that, especially this season, merits reflection.

The national debt, much like our Thanksgiving appetites, has swelled to gargantuan proportions. Budget gluttony practically defies the laws of fiscal gravity. In 2023, we reached a record $33 trillion in national debt and a $1.7 trillion deficit. Politicians have opted for the equivalent of year-round sumptuous feasts while ignoring the costs.

Contrast this childish gluttony with the festive abundance on our Thanksgiving tables — an abundance resulting from responsible planning and budgeting. After all, we can’t eat like this every day. Such mature behavior seems alien to politicians.

Indeed, Thanksgiving is not merely about the harvest, but also about conservation and preparation for the winter to come. Our ancestors understood this. They knew that a squandered harvest means privation in the months ahead. A family that spends beyond its means this week might face immediate financial consequences, and it can’t save the bill for the kids to pay when they grow up.

That behavior is reserved for Washington politicians. It’s a cycle of deferral transforming the national debt from a temporary ledger of manageable liabilities into a looming threat to our children’s future.

Similarly, most Americans understand how to make trade-offs. Thanksgiving dinner has gotten a lot more expensive. The American Farm Bureau Federation’s annual survey estimates that the cost of a standard turkey dinner is about 25% higher than in 2019. Holiday travel is also a major holiday expense, as nearly 29% of Americans planned to spend more than $500 on it last year.

And with prices soaring, our behavior surrounding the holidays also changed. Last year, 33% of Americans said that high inflation wouldn’t affect their Thanksgiving plans, but most looked for ways to cut costs, including reducing the number of dishes prepared or asking guests to contribute food or funds. One-in-four considered skipping Thanksgiving due to the surge in prices. Others drove rather than flying to visit family to make up for the surge in airfares.

Imagine if we applied the same careful planning to our national budget. If Congress behaved more like American families, we’d see better ways to offset the costs of emergencies like the COVID pandemic. And as inflation emerged (thanks to their overspending), Congress would slow down their spending instead of doubling down with more spending on green subsidies, loan forgiveness, and union favors.

Other expenses are more predictable. Thanksgiving rolls around once a year, and families expect one expensive feast. If they don’t know exactly how many people will come, they might make a little extra and buy fewer groceries while they enjoy any leftovers.

Once again, Congress can’t seem to manage this. After boosting spending during an emergency, they should restrain spending and reduce deficits as peace and prosperity return. But legislators fail to plan, sometimes treat past emergency spending like the new normal, and deficits and debt only seem to expand.

The best example of the failure to plan is, as usual, Social Security. Sometime in the 2030s, it will run a cashflow deficit — meaning payroll taxes won’t be enough to cover retirees’ benefits — requiring benefit cuts or more unsustainable, unacceptable increases in the debt.

Any American with a speck of pocketbook savvy would plan and avoid a similarly foreseeable problem on its own financial horizon. But Congress didn’t. Unsurprisingly, though, Congress’ problem has progressed so far already that any eventual reforms will be more painful than they needed to be.

So, as we give thanks for the year’s prosperity and gather in the warmth of family and friends, let us also spare a thought for America’s fiscal path. The national debt, if left unchecked, threatens to undermine the very foundations of our economic stability. It is the antithesis of the Thanksgiving spirit, which cherishes abundance without excess and gratitude coupled with responsibility.

And after we pause to enjoy this year’s harvest, let’s also demand that national fiscal policy mirrors the values we celebrate at our tables: thrift, foresight, and care for the welfare of those who will sit at this table long after we are gone. Let the legacy of our generation be one of fiscal responsibility, so that future Thanksgivings will be celebrated not under a cloud of debt, but in the clear light of prosperity earned and preserved.