Hardy Women

William Collins 656pp £25 The Week Bookshop £19.99

The fame of the novelist and poet Thomas Hardy rested largely on the heroines he created, said Norma Clarke in Literary Review. With the likes of Tess Durbeyfield (Tess of the d’Urbervilles) and Sue Bridehead (Jude the Obscure), he displayed, as one young reader wrote to him, a “complete understanding of a woman’s soul”. But as Paula Byrne shows in this fascinating book, the women Hardy knew in real life were less fortunate. Byrne doggedly details them all, from Hardy’s “strong-minded” mother, Jemima, to the “pretty girls” who “turned his head” in his youth, to his wives, Emma Gifford and Florence Dugdale (pictured, with Hardy). Hardy’s women, she concludes, “paid a large price” for the “magnificent fictional women he invented”.

“In a sign of trouble to come, young Hardy fell in love violently and often,” said Susie Goldsbrough in The Times. His first serious entanglement, says Byrne, “was with a Dorset maidservant called Eliza Nicholls, whom he dumped for her young sister”. In his mid-30s, Hardy married Emma, a solicitor’s daughter. Although initially happy, the marriage soured as “Emma gained weight” and became increasingly eccentric. By the time of her death, aged 72, in 1912, she was living in the attic of their Dorset home – and the much younger Florence was living with them, having been employed as Hardy’s typist. After Hardy married Florence in 1914, she had to put up with him “enthusiastically mourning the wife he had spent years complaining about” – and who now became the subject of an “astonishing” series of love poems. Although Byrne is sometimes hampered by a lack of evidence (Hardy destroyed most of Emma’s letters, together with the journal she wrote about him), this is still an “absorbing” portrait of the women who suffered for Hardy’s art.