The Daily Telegraph

Rule of Six may be a no-deal diversion

- James Le Fanu Email medical questions confidenti­ally to Dr James Le Fanu at drjames @telegraph.co.uk

Last week’s press release from Public Health England drawing attention to “concerns” about the broad increase in the number of Covid cases should have added the necessary rider that this has not been paralleled by a rise in either hospital admissions or the mortality rate – which both gratifying­ly remain obstinatel­y low. This is in line with all similar pandemics where over time the effects of the virus tend to become a lot less serious and deadly. So why the need for the new measures announced last Thursday – “The Rule of Six” – with Covid marshals to ensure social distancing in pubs and restaurant­s? “The rules change constantly, seemingly without a rational set of objectives,” observed former Tory Party treasurer Sir Mick Davis in this paper. “The UK remains trapped in its own universe of fear and inconsiste­ncy.”

Perhaps the Government’s reluctance to encourage a speedy return to normality is a deliberate ploy, suggests retired intensive care consultant Ray Sinclair in The Guardian. Perpetuati­ng anxiety and chaos, he alleges, will distract attention from the prospect of a no-deal Brexit, allowing it to slip through “with less coverage and challenge”. Machiavell­ian – or what?

Meanwhile, Matt Hancock’s promise of much wider availabili­ty of testing will certainly further boost the numbers found to be infected – albeit without, for many, having any symptoms. It should, however, allow those incarcerat­ed in care homes to see more of their loved ones. All this requires is that a designated relative be tested which, if negative, will sanction a prolonged visit without the necessity to sit outside wearing a mask. What could be simpler?

Healing pains

The plight of the woman afflicted at monthly intervals by an excruciati­ng pain on the right side of her chest (“I fear I am about to die”) radiating to her back and under the arm has prompted several possible explanatio­ns. Based on personal experience, a couple of women attribute it to her mastectomy four years previously with the subsequent fibrotic healing of tissues compressin­g a nerve in the chest wall. “My first episode occurred when reaching to retrieve my napkin in a restaurant,” writes a woman who had a lumpectomy a decade ago. “I screamed so loudly everyone jumped.” It is also pointed out that a “silent” osteoporot­ic fracture of a vertebra can cause a similar pain by compressin­g a nerve as it exits the spinal cord.

A further very different possibilit­y would be colic due to gallstones. “The descriptio­n of this pain mimics my own precisely,” writes another woman woken regularly at 2am. Since having her gallbladde­r removed last October she has slept through the night. Alternativ­ely, emeritus Prof David Allison is fairly confident this is “precordial catch syndrome” – a spontaneou­s excruciati­ng pain in the chest wall that occurs at rest. While its cause is unknown, he notes (reassuring­ly) it is “entirely benign” and will eventually resolve.

Miraculous cure

Finally, my thanks to a reader for passing on the near miraculous cure for his 20-year history of irritable bowel syndrome of the diarrhoea predominan­t type, associated with urgency (“a sudden and pressing need to go to the loo”) and only modestly mitigated by taking industrial quantities of Imodium. This has necessitat­ed certain lifestyle changes such as sitting on the aisle seat on trains and in the cinema and staying in a hotel rather than with relatives and friends. He has along the way acquired an intimate knowledge of the location and quality of the public lavatories in his home town – M&S’S being the most favoured, “always immaculate­ly clean with a vacant seat”.

Then late last year, his family doctor suggested simplifyin­g his blood pressure regime of three different pills: doxazosin, diltiazem and lisinopril, advising he discontinu­e the diltiazem. A fortnight later he realised he had stopped worrying about where the nearest loo might be. Nine months on, his stock of Imodium remains untouched. And, for good measure, his blood pressure remains well within the normal range.

In line with all pandemics, over time the effects of the virus become a lot less deadly

 ??  ?? Rule change: do we need new measures when the mortality rate remains low?
Rule change: do we need new measures when the mortality rate remains low?
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom