Sunday World (South Africa)

Safa must probe coaches’ conduct

Allegation­s are just that until proven

- Xolile Mtshazo

There is no smoke without fire, so goes the old adage.

The disturbing finger-pointing emanating from both the Bafana Bafana and Banyana Banyana camps, relating to the allegation­s involving coaches Stuart Baxter and Desiree Ellis, must be laid at Safa’s door to investigat­e.

Fingers have been pointed at the two national team coaches pertaining to the abuse of power at the Africa Cup of Nations (Afcon) and the Women’s World Cup.

These cannot go unchalleng­ed, unproven and unverified by the national associatio­n.

It is worrying to learn over the past few days that in the days leading to the continenta­l and world finals, and during these tournament, both Baxter and Ellis targeted certain players including members of their technical staff, whom they viewed as troublemak­ers.

In the aftermath of the Afcon in Egypt, it has been revealed that dependable midfielder Hlompho Kekana, despite defending for the better part of the game against Morocco, was told by Baxter to go out and score. It was a case of “my way or the highway”.

The same Kekana, it is said, was so peeved with the coach he stormed out of one of the meetings with the coach. He was benched against Nigeria.

It is now history that even when advised to give forward Thembinkos­i Lorch a run in the group stage matches, the unwavering Baxter adamantly stood his ground. Many a Bafana supporters have been asking: What does the coach have against Lorch?

After some pressure and persuasion from home, the Bucs striker started against Egypt and won the match with a thriller of a goal.

Again, the Scottish-Briton saw it fit to substitute him after 58 minutes against Nigeria, and Bafana lost.

Even when the coach was told to give Percy Tau a break, the coach refused to heed advice from his assistants – Molefi Ntseki and Andre Arendse – it has been revealed.

Then comes the abortive “Ellis Mission” marking Banyana’s maiden World Cup appearance. Banyana were already in disarray even before landing in France, with the dropping of veteran midfielder Nompumelel­o Nyandeni from the final squad for being outspoken and candid with the coach.

Her omission divided the players right down the middle as she is regarded as a leader by her teammates and, to crown it all, was due for her 150th cap.

Long-serving striker Jermaine Seoposenwe was also shown the door before the team left for France for engaging the coach on tactics.

Players from both Bafana and Banyana have kept mum on the alarming treatment they apparently have to endure from their coaches for fear of reprisals, but there are a few who do speak out before or after retiring, which does not help their cause.

There have been alarming allegation­s of favouritis­m and bias when squads are selected and starting team lists are drawn up. Both Baxter and Ellis have been fingered to be vindictive when dealing with those whom they don’t see eye-to-eye.

Instead of applauding and celebratin­g Bafana’s silencing of the Egyptians in their most exciting match to date, and Ellis for taking the women’s national team to the World Cup, but bombing out in the first round, Safa must launch parallel investigat­ions to get to the bottom of these claims.

Once again, the revelation­s will remain allegation­s until the football associatio­n gets to the bottom of it all.

 ?? Photos: Veli Nhlapo ?? Stuart Baxter is alleged to have ignored assistants’ advice.
Photos: Veli Nhlapo Stuart Baxter is alleged to have ignored assistants’ advice.
 ??  ?? Desiree Ellis is ‘vindictive’ to those who oppose her.
Desiree Ellis is ‘vindictive’ to those who oppose her.
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa