Who is Delhi’s boss? SC verdict on power tussle today
The Supreme Court will pronounce its verdict on Wednesday on a batch of petitions filed by the Kejriwal government questioning the overriding powers of the lieutenantgovernor ( L- G) of Delhi under Article 239AA of the Constitution.
A five- judge Constitution bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra had reserved verdict on December 6, 2017 on the petitions which contended that the L- G could not claim absolute executive powers in the administration of the Union Territory.
The Kejriwal government argued that the L- G had created a situation where no bureaucrat is obeying directions of the ministers and chief minister Arvind Kejriwal. The L- G, it said, was holding meetings separately with officials without ministers which was against the democratic governance of an elected government.
The court heard arguments on a batch of special leave petitions filed by the Delhi government against a judgment of the Delhi high court, which held that the L- G was the administrative head of the city and was not bound by the aid and advice of the chief minister or council of ministers.
The HC also held that the then L- G Najeeb Jung was its administrative head and all decisions will have to be taken with his consent
A Constitution bench had reserved verdict on December 6, 2017 on the petitions which contended that the L- G could not claim absolute executive powers in the administration of the Union Territory
and concurrence.
Assailing this finding the Kejriwal government said the HC verdict subverted the democratic governance structure put by a constitutional arrangement, which recognises Delhi’s special powers despite being a Union Territory. It argued that Article 239AA could not be used by the L- G to frustrate the constitutional mandate for an elected government in Delhi.
The appeals said, “If the L- G the boss in terms of governance and decisionmaking process, then Parliament in its wisdom would not have provided for a council of ministers headed by a chief minister, who were answerable to the Legislative Assembly. It was submitted that several of the government files remained pending with the L- G, some for over a year.”
The Centre had argued that Delhi continued to be a Union Territory and all decisions would have to be taken only with the approval of the L- G. The Delhi government cannot bypass the L- G in the decision making process.