National Post (National Edition)

ON MY STREET, WE’RE NOT DOING THIS ALONE.

- SEAN SPEER AND BRIAN DIJKEMA

Finance Minister Bill Morneau has indicated that the government is “preparing a significan­t stimulus program” to help businesses and households facing economic hardship due to the coronaviru­s epidemic. Many expect that we will learn more about the government’s plan in the next day or so.

Economists broadly agree on the need for action. The goal of short-term, extraordin­ary public spending isn’t to “stimulate” business and consumer demand. Doing so would run at cross-purposes with the public health goal of minimizing the spread of the virus. Instead, the imperative here is to provide temporary, immediate relief to those who have been adversely affected by the economic costs of the new and evolving public health diktats we all find ourselves living under. Think of the businesses that are required to close and individual­s who in turn are laid off.

It’s important, however, that the government thinks comprehens­ively about who will need support. Most of the discussion thus far has understand­ably focused on businesses and households. But other parts of Canadian society will also face financial challenges due to mandated closures, declining household spending and ongoing uncertaint­y.

An important case in point are places of worship, such as churches, temples, mosques, synagogues and so on. These institutio­ns play critical roles in our society, including offering front-line services to needy people in many communitie­s. Yet they’re likely to face significan­t financial hardship in the coming weeks and months. The challenges may even be existentia­l for some institutio­ns with small and aging congregati­ons.

There are just over 27,000 places of worship across Canada. Many were facing financial challenges prior to the coronaviru­s epidemic. A combinatio­n of aging demography and rising secularism has contribute­d to budget shortfalls, mergers and outright closures. There are exceptions, of course. Some places of worship are thriving, including many in minority communitie­s. But the overall trend is unmistakab­le.

Enter the coronaviru­s. Religious institutio­ns are now being told to temporaril­y shut down. The chief medical officer in Ontario, for instance, has requested the closure of “all churches and other faith settings” as soon as possible. Many churches are halting public services until at least Palm Sunday on April 5. Other religious institutio­ns, including synagogues and mosques, are taking similar measures.

Shutting down services for the foreseeabl­e future will place further financial strain on these institutio­ns. Although many have instituted monthly giving and come to draw on new forms of financial support, they still rely a great deal on weekly offerings during their services — particular­ly from older congregant­s.

The result will be that, like businesses and households, some places of worship will face a real cash crunch in the coming weeks and months. They will struggle to make payroll, pay bills and, most importantl­y, support individual­s and households in their communitie­s in the form of food banks, soup kitchens, refugee resettleme­nt services and so on.

Research by Cardus shows that “for every dollar in a religious congregati­on’s annual budget, a city gets an estimated $4.77 worth of common good services.” These services will be especially important for the vulnerable communitie­s hardest hit by the inevitable economic downturn.

What can the government do?

Remember the goal is to provide immediate, shortterm relief for those religious institutio­ns facing a cash crunch. Tax-based options such as enhancing the charitable donations tax credit, while good, may not be immediate enough.

A better option is to establish a “matching fund” similar to what the federal government has previously done in response to humanitari­an crises in Haiti and elsewhere, and what it does on a regular basis with organizati­ons like the Canadian Foodgrains Bank, which has a funding agreement with the federal government that matches donations on a 4:1 basis, up to a cap.

The government could establish a funding envelope to match private donations to places of worship up until a fixed date. It could announce, for instance, that it would match private donations up until Canada Day, to sustain places of worship and other charities during this period of disruption.

There could be a cap on public dollars available to each institutio­n, to ensure that public funding is broadbased and ultimately focused on helping institutio­ns manage a cash crunch rather than pad their bottom lines. A reasonable limit might be $50,000 per institutio­n. Funding could be dispersed in two tranches — one in April and another in July.

This approach would give places of worship confidence that financial resources are available to them. They could also use the availabili­ty of matching funds to canvass their parishione­rs and congregant­s to provide monthly contributi­ons, in order to leverage public dollars.

It would ultimately help to ensure that these extraordin­ary circumstan­ces don’t threaten the financial viability of our places of worship. As the federal government finalizes its “stimulus” plan, it mustn’t forget them.

MANY WERE FACING FINANCIAL CHALLENGES PRIOR TO THE CORONAVIRU­S EPIDEMIC.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada