Gulf Today

Ilhan Omar is reminding House Democrats how hard it is to be in charge

- By Jon Healey

This week House Democrats took up what may be the most important government­reform effort in decades — HR 1, a package of anti-corruption proposals — and buried it under an avalanche of hot takes about anti-semitism.

To paraphrase «Hustle & Flow,» it›s hard out here for a majority.

All you liberals who delighted at the many times Republican Speakers John Boehner (ROhio) and Paul Ryan (R-wis.) were undermined by uncompromi­sing fringe factions within the House GOP may now see the world through their eyes. At the time, many a pundit opined that Boehner and Ryan had to coddle tea partiers or their successors in disruption, the House Freedom Caucus, or else lose the gavel. But the problem is more fundamenta­l than that: Those dissident factions had enough votes to scutle legislatio­n if they sided with Democrats, which they were more than willing to do, even on bills that only a conservati­ve could love.

So the speaker had litle choice but to accommodat­e them on measures that Democrats opposed, which is almost everything the Gopcontrol­led House moved.

Similarly, current Speaker Nancy Pelosi (Dsan Francisco) has a sizable faction of younger, more liberal members agitating for quick action on such polarizing proposals as the Green New Deal and single-payer healthcare. A bill by sophomore Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-wash.) to extend Medicare to all Americans quickly garnered 106 Democratic cosponsors (and no Republican­s). Try telling that group to sit back down and wait their turn.

What Pelosi can do is let the disciplini­ng function of the legislativ­e process temper the outsize ambitions of new members. Developing a workable, affordable transition to single payer, if such a thing exists, will take months of hearings and legislativ­e drating sessions. Dito for charting a path to a carbon-neutral economy. If the proponents of such ideas are serious, as some of them clearly are, they›ll be willing to put in the time and effort.

A potentiall­y bigger problem for Pelosi and her party, though, is the way a handful of individual members are seemingly defining the entire House Democratic caucus. This week it was Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-minn.), whose inability to avoid anti-semitic land mines in her critiques of US policy toward Israel has given President Trump the opportunit­y to paint Democrats as the anti-israel party.

This is mystifying. There have been outliers in Congress for years in both parties, including weirdos such as James Traficant (D-ohio) and Dana Rohrabache­r (R-costa Mesa) and extremists such as Dennis Kucinich (D-ohio) and Michele Bachmann (R-minn.). And while they occasional­ly embarrasse­d their colleagues, they were never held up as representa­tive.

Yet Omar somehow gets held up as the face of the Democratic Party?

The House Democratic leadership is partly to blame for this. Republican­s› criticism of Omar prompted Democrats to take action against her to prove that they were as tough on anti-semitism as the next elected official, rather than counting on the public to recognize the statements of a single, obscure pol for what they were. That was mistake No. 1.

Mistake No. 2 was refusing to single out Omar for criticism, or even denounce just the anti-semitism implicit in the tropes she invoked. Instead, being Democrats, the resolution they offered also denounced a laundry list of other ills, for fear of singling out the person who caused the problem in the first place.

The result was the sort of inoffensiv­e, motherhood-and-apple-pie declaratio­n that anyone and everyone could vote for, which didn›t exactly buff the party›s credibilit­y as a foe of anti-semitism. Happily for Pelosi, Republican­s can›t stay on message any beter as a minority than they could as a majority. Twenty-three Republican­s actually voted against the resolution — ostensibly because it didn›t rebuke Omar directly — inviting whoever runs against them next year to ask why they defended racism, anti-semitism and the host of other forms of discrimina­tion the resolution opposed.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Bahrain