The National (Scotland)

Oligarchs, royalty and foreign banks all flouting Scots land laws

- BY JAMIE MANN AND PETRA MATIJEVIC Money laundering · Corruption · Banking · World Finances · Finance · Business · Crime · Liberal Democrats · Earth · Europe · United Kingdom · North Lanarkshire · British Virgin Islands · Ukraine · Australia · Vladimir Putin · Dubai · United Arab Emirates · Qatar · Kingussie · Alberta · Glasgow · JPMorgan Chase · HSBC Holdings · Royal Bank of Canada · Isle of Man · Gibraltar · KGB · Bermuda · Port Glasgow · Alexander · United States of America · Scottish National Party · Willie Rennie · Scottish Government · estates of the realm · Scotland · Calgary House · Aberfeldy · Andy Wightman · Vladimir Lisin · Ayr · Balmaha · Turcan Connell · Guernsey · The Bank of N. T. Butterfield & Son Limited · Dunfermline · Community Land Scotland · Transparency International UK

RUSSIAN oligarchs, billionair­es, foreign government­s, internatio­nal royalty, and banking giants are among those behind nearly 1000 offshore entities that are illegally flouting the land control registry, The Ferret can reveal.

We found that around two-thirds (956) of the 1447 overseas firms which own Scottish land and should appear on the publicly available log are absent.

Their assets, typically owned via tax and secrecy havens, include castles, sporting estates and prime city centre real estate worth tens of millions of pounds.

Offending landowners have been linked to fraud and money laundering, while some firms that oversee landowning entities previously failed to prevent serious financial crime risks.

The register was introduced by the Scottish Government in 2022 with the stated intention of uncovering who controls swathes of the country’s land. But the widespread non-compliance we have uncovered means that who controls swathes of Scotland remains a mystery. Meanwhile, some who benefit from public subsidies for land management are avoiding scrutiny.

Land and anti-corruption campaigner­s claimed the register had “failed” and required an overhaul with proper checks and enforcemen­t.

The LibDems called for an “immediate and thorough investigat­ion”, while the Greens said our findings show that parliament must ensure “legislatio­n is properly enforced”.

The controller­s of 60% (1766) of the 2959 offshore-owned properties we analysed were not disclosed on the Register of Persons Holding a Controlled Interest in Land (RCI).

But The Ferret was able to identify hundreds of the beneficial owners behind them.

As well as some of the world’s wealthiest people, they include real estate bosses, wealth managers and veteran lawyers who proclaim legal prudence.

The 956 offshore companies should each risk up to a £5000 fine for failing to register – as much as £4.8 million in total – which a land expert derided as a “weak” deterrent. Regardless, no authority was tasked with monitoring the RCI after the rules came into force in 2024.

The RCI’s failed transparen­cy aims

AFTER regulation­s were passed unanimousl­y by the Scottish Parliament, the RCI was launched with the aim of boosting transparen­cy about who makes decisions about the management or use of land.

Then-land reform minister Màiri McAllan said it would make Scotland “a frontrunne­r in Europe and deliver greater transparen­cy than any other part of the UK”. She wanted to ensure that control of land could not be obscured, including “via overseas trusts or entities”.

Registers of Scotland was tasked with establishi­ng and maintainin­g – but not enforcing – the RCI, which said it would “deliver valuable insight to citizens and communitie­s”.

RCI rules state that “recorded persons” – which explicitly include overseas entities – must log details about themselves, their land, and their “associates”. Recorded persons are landowners or tenants on a longer 20-year lease, while associates control the land.

We assessed non-compliance by checking whether the 1447 entities listed on Registers of Scotland’s latest report into offshore property owners as of December 31 2025, featured on the RCI on March 20 this year.

Of the 956 companies that didn’t, we identified hundreds who disclosed their beneficial owners in the UK Register of Overseas Entities (ROE), which has considerab­ly stronger monitoring, enforcemen­t and penalties than the RCI.

Castles and estates

LARGE estates are among unregister­ed properties, making it unclear who makes decisions about a range of issues, including conservati­on, sporting activities, forestry, energy projects and public access.

Parts, or all of Kinpurnie Castle in Angus, Calgary Castle in Mull, Farleyer Estate near Aberfeldy, Murdostoun Castle in North Lanarkshir­e, Auchinfroe House estate near Cardross and Edinburgh’s Dundas Estate are absent from the RCI. So are the Gualin, Struy, Pitlundie, Shurrery and the Pitmain and Glenbancho­r Highland estates.

LAND expert Andy Wightman notified Police Scotland of non-compliance by the owners of North Glenbuchat in Aberdeensh­ire, among others. The estate – reportedly owned by a wealthy aristocrat with strong ties to the royal family – has since registered.

Wightman claimed officers referred two cases to the Crown Office, but it declined to take action. Police allegedly did not act on other breaches he reported, although some were still outstandin­g, he added.

The Ferret found that Aberuchill Castle, an unregister­ed Perthshire estate, is owned by Liudmila Lisina via a British Virgin Islands firm. In 2022, it was reportedly held by her husband, Russian oligarch Vladimir Lisin.

The billionair­e is sanctioned in Ukraine, Canada and Australia for allegedly providing steel to Kremlin weapons firms and bankrollin­g Vladimir Putin’s party.

Foreign government­s and banks

OVERSEAS government­s and banking giants are behind some offending firms.

They include the Crown Prince of Dubai – a member of the UAE’s ruling royal family and owner of a firm behind Rynagoup Wood near Forres.

The State of Qatar enjoys unrecorded salmon fishing rights in rivers at Cluny Estate near Kingussie via a Jersey firm, while the government­s of Singapore and Alberta, Canada are behind nearly £35m of unregister­ed Glasgow property via Luxembourg and Jersey entities.

When contacted by The Ferret, Singapore said responsibi­lity lay with its Jersey firm, which had now pursued registrati­on.

A subsidiary of JPMorgan Chase, one of the world’s largest banks, has a £28m unregister­ed city property portfolio, while a Jersey firm controlled by an HSBC subsidiary failed to log property in Ayr, Elgin and Peterhead. HSBC declined to comment.

Parts of Buchanan Castle Estate and Balmaha Bay, held by a Royal Bank of Canada-owned Jersey firm, are absent from the RCI, although properties it did log name the Duke of Montrose as a controller.

Lawyers and trustees

MANY firms which failed to comply with Scottish land laws are controlled by legal profession­als.

The chair of Scottish law firm Turcan Connell, Alexander Garden, offers governance advice to clients including “landed estate owners”. But a Jersey firm he administer­s failed to register parts of Dundas Estate. Turcan Connell declined to comment due to “client confidenti­ality”.

The boss of Edinburgh’s Qmile, Paul Curran, owns a non-compliant Isle of Man company behind the city’s luxury Craighouse developmen­t, while Line Trust Corporatio­n, which is linked to Gibraltar’s top law firm, administer­s an entity with unrecorded Aberdeen land.

Last year, The Ferret revealed that a British Virgin Islands firm was secretly owned by a KGB-linked Russian oligarch praised by Putin. It has still not logged its dozens of car parking spaces near Glasgow airport.

Neither have offshore firms including care home giant HC-One, steel magnate Sanjeev Gupta, and US real estate boss, Keith Breslauer, whose Luxembourg firm bought the Livingston Designer Outlet for £101m in 2017.

Other sky-high value unregister­ed properties are Standard Life House in Edinburgh, acquired for £94m in 2015 by a Guernsey company co-owned by an Indian billionair­e, and a £68.5m chunk of Edinburgh’s luxury Quartermil­e developmen­t, owned by a firm controlled by German investment managers.

Representa­tives of the Quartermil­e firm vowed to register after being questioned by The Ferret.

Financial crime links

SOME of those behind unregister­ed offshore firms have been mired in dirty money allegation­s or safeguardi­ng failures.

Bermuda’s Butterfiel­d Bank oversees a BVI firm which bought property in Port Glasgow, and the Sweet Chestnut pub in Dunfermlin­e in 2021. Months later, it paid $5.6m to the US government to settle a tax evasion case.

Michael Burke Jr, part of one of Ireland’s richest families, owns £25.5m of land in Edinburgh, and the former Gretna Golf Course in Dumfriessh­ire via Guernsey firms. He was linked to a £5bn crypto money laundering scam in 2024, but denied any involvemen­t. Burke could not be reached.

Vistra Trust, a trustee of a firm which owns East Calder property, was fined £640,000 in 2022 for breaching Singapore’s anti-money laundering and terrorist financing rules, while Belasko, the trustee of an entity with nine Highland properties, was fined for flouting these safeguards in Jersey in 2024.

In the same year, Guernsey’s financial regulator fined Zedra Trust Company and blackliste­d a former officer for helping to hide the beneficial ownership of an entity by a businessma­n arrested for suspected fraud, bribery, and corruption. A branch of Zedra administer­s a firm with unrecorded property in Paisley.

Umena Management failed to register its Cairngorm land. In 2024, we highlighte­d that Alexander Jeeves – the head of a group which ultimately owns the trust behind Umena – was entangled in an alleged £800m money laundering and fraud scam. Jeeves said his clients had managed the US scheme, but he paid a settlement and the judgment was lifted.

Calls for ‘immediate and thorough investigat­ion’

LAND expert Wightman said The Ferret’s investigat­ion shows that “the RCI has failed in a big way and at the heart of the problem is a failure to monitor compliance and prosecute those persons who have committed offences”.

James Bolton-Jones, senior policy researcher at Spotlight on Corruption, agreed.

“A failure to introduce a compliance monitoring mechanism completely undermines the credibilit­y and effectiven­ess of the register,” he said. “The role of lawyers and wealth advisers – who we know can be both

It shouldn’t be down to hardworkin­g journalist­s to uncover informatio­n like this which should be widely available

witting and unwitting enablers of money laundering – in flouting the rules is particular­ly troubling.”

Dr Josh Doble of Community Land Scotland called for a comprehens­ive system to collect data on land ownership and use. “If we don’t know who ultimately owns land, we cannot address corruption, poor land management or start to build the policies that will fully tackle the big challenges facing society,” he argued.

Juliet Swann of Transparen­cy Internatio­nal UK highlighte­d that the SNP’s 2026 manifesto promised “robust anti-avoidance measures” to “make land ownership transparen­t”. She offered to help ministers develop an effective enforcemen­t plan. Otherwise, “loopholes will continue to be exploited”, warned Swann.

GREEN MSP Ariane Burgess said a functionin­g RCI was necessary to reveal who benefits from public money for tree planting, peatland restoratio­n and other support payments. But The Ferret’s findings “underline how much work we still need to do to hold the vested interests accountabl­e and to ensure that our legislatio­n is properly enforced".

She added: “It shouldn’t be down to hard-working journalist­s to uncover informatio­n like this which should be widely available.”

Lib Dem MSP Willie Rennie added: “This requires an immediate and thorough investigat­ion as there is little point in passing new laws if they are not enforced.”

Registers of Scotland stressed that it has no role or powers relating to compliance or enforcemen­t. The Scottish Government said: “Enforcemen­t of the law is an independen­t matter for Police Scotland.”

Police Scotland said it was working to “increase awareness and understand­ing of the legislatio­n” while “any report received will be thoroughly investigat­ed to establish if there has been any criminalit­y".

Every beneficial owner named in this article was approached for comment.

 ?? ??
 ?? ??
 ?? Picture: Anthony O'Neil Picture: Gordon Terris ?? Aberuchill Castle from the slopes of Crappich Hill
Land reformer Andy Wightman
Picture: Anthony O'Neil Picture: Gordon Terris Aberuchill Castle from the slopes of Crappich Hill Land reformer Andy Wightman
 ?? ?? The Ferret is an editoriall­y independen­t, not-for-profit co-operative run by its journalist­s and subscriber­s. You can find it at https://theferret. scot/ and can subscribe for £5 a month here: https://theferret. scot/subscribe/
The Ferret is an editoriall­y independen­t, not-for-profit co-operative run by its journalist­s and subscriber­s. You can find it at https://theferret. scot/ and can subscribe for £5 a month here: https://theferret. scot/subscribe/

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom